Stephens Valuation and Consultancy Pty Ltd


                         Extracting Wealth for your Business
News & Updates


05-11-2015 
"Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation."

Celebrating our New Trade Mark
2012 
www.quarryvaluations.com has now been registered as a Trade Mark. We thank all the people who look at the website and who have given it its high profile reputation as without YOU we would not have achieved this status. Keep looking.

 

See our latest article on Quarry Capitalisation Rates.

 

Celebrating 25 years in Real Estate

 

We now have over 250 fully analysed quarry sales and lease transactions throughout Australia and New Zealand. We hold details of over 50 lease transactions, so if you need a lease renewal, then give us a call.


Keep coming back for more updates shortly.


See www.quarrysalesaustralia.com for quarries for sale and lease.


We were No 1 for Quarry Valuations worldwide on Google and Yahoo and many other search engines from 2009 to 2011 and hope to keep it that way for 2012. Thanks for looking and making us the most popular quarry related site worldwide.


We also do Expert Witness valuations so give us a call to see if we can assist.

Archive
06-12-2011 
Rod Stephens has produced two thesis reports namely The definition of the word Minerals in relation to the UK Extractive Industry and The Valuation of Long Term Interests  A case study of the acquisition of WMCs Olympic Dam Mine by BHP Billiton (Distinction). These reports can be made available on request for selected parties only. Terms and Conditions apply.

This website is Copyright reserved. Our itellectual property is not to be copied or used for commercial purposes or any other purpose without our express permission in writing. The opinions and research carried out is the original work of Stephens Valuation and Consultancy Pty Ltd and are not to be quoted or used for any purpose without our written permission. Please have respect for these conditions.

Anyone entering any other section of this website does so on the above understanding and is subject to those conditions.


Archive

 

 

 

 

Stephens Valuation & Consultancy Pty Ltd

 

Roderick Stephens BSc (Hons) MC MRICS AAPI (CPV)
 
www.quarryvaluations.com is a Registered Trade Mark
 
     
for Quarry Valuations
 
  Introduction

 

2011 has to date involved a number of major quarry acquisitions which has created a great deal of interest from smaller quarry operators as to the value implications to their quarries. Although every quarry is unique, and even if they do share the same geology as another quarry, they are often located in different markets, and may have specific planning conditions or other licensing regulations imposed which set them apart, and so every individual quarry value needs to be assessed by itself. Most of the individual site circumstances are reflected in the quarry royalty, which for valuation purposes is multiplied by the estimated future output to form an annual income (derived from the actual profits or the rental), which is then capitalised over the life of the quarry. The purpose of this paper is to consider the application of capitalisation rates for quarry valuations, which is the main driver of the quarry income and if wrongly applied, can produce significant over valuations.

 

Market Evidence

 

The best way to assess the capitalisation rate for quarry valuations is to consider the market evidence of past transactions. Most of the major quarrying companies are listed either on the ASX or other international share markets, and due to the necessity for disclosure have to publish information on acquisitions within their annual reports or within disclosure statements to the various stock markets. Consequently many of the major quarry business sales that have taken place in Australia over the last 10 years or so, have been made public and many of the companies provide their opinion of the earnings multiplier for the transaction, which can be converted to establish the capitalisation rate derived. Coupled with this there is also additional information within the public domain that allows quarry valuers to decipher the details of each quarry transaction, in order to assess likely values for individual sites, which also then allows the quarry royalties to be calculated for the transaction.

 

For the quarrying industry the capitalisation rates have been broadly consistent over a number of years. We set out below a range of capitalisation rate charts to illustrate the most recent trends in the market.

 

As with most long term valuations it is usual to consider the long term trend of capitalisation rates to best reflect the typical future trends.

 

Capitalisation Rates  Long Term Trends

 

The chart below indicates that the long term trend has involved an increase from 12.0% to 13.4% over the last 10 years or so, but has been generally consistent with the range of plus or minus 2.0% of the trend, with a few minor exceptions. Alternatively you could take the average of all the transactions which equates to around 13.0%. Therefore quarry sales transactions have generally not followed other property market trends, which up to the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) had all virtually showed shrinking yields, which following the GFC rose quite sharply and have perhaps in the last few years stabilised somewhat, but are still at much higher levels than the pre GFC scenario. So quite clearly there has never been any link or relationship to other property yields and the quarry industry operates in its own separate market.
 
 

 

The key thing to recognise for many quarry related assets is that the greatest amount of risk is generally involved with the geology, whereby sudden changes to the sites geology can impact on the quality and types of products produced, and in turn their selling prices. However the larger quarry companies tend to carry out extensive drilling programmes at most of their quarries in order to remove many of the geological risks. The other risk factors involve the fluctuating outputs of quarries, and in turn revenues, and again the major quarry companies can minimise these risks, with internal supply arrangements to their own pre mixed concrete plant, asphalt plants, concrete products work and other similar operations. So for larger quarry companies with diversification benefits then they can absorb risk much better than smaller quarry companies, who have a much higher risk exposure to the market fluctuations.

 

Capitalisation Rates  Post GFC
 
 
 
The chart above considers the circumstances of the market post the GFC and shows the trend as dropping from 14.0% to 12.8%, which we believe provides a more accurate assessment of the market over this period, but more importantly is broadly in line with the more recent long term trend of 13.4% or the long term industry average of 13.0%.
 
Capitalisation Rates  Short Term Trends

 

The chart below shows the trend over the last 18 months or so, which again shows a tightening from 13.2% to 12.6%. Again this appears to be consistent with the stabilising of the quarrying industry post the GFC, and indicates an average of around 13.0% which is also broadly in line with the long term trend figure derived of 13.4% and confirms the long term industry average of 13.0%.
 

 

Conclusion of Quarry Industry Capitalisation Rates

 

Both the long term and short term trends for capitalisation rates are typically within the range of 12% to 14%, with the current long term average derived as 13.4%, the long term average of 13.0% and the short term average of 12.7%, and so an industry wide capitalisation rate of 13.0% would generally be a well accepted benchmark for use as a starting point for assessment of any quarry valuation.

 

It should be borne in mind that the above charts are for businesses sold as a going concern and we would expect these to have a lower risk due to existing goodwill and diversification benefits compared to a single entity. Although it should also be considered that the capitalisation rate adopted for the quarries would perhaps be lower for well located high output operations compared to more remote low output operations. We believe that an independent quarry operator would warrant a similar overall capitalisation rate to those of the market as a whole. We would then make adjustments to reflect the local circumstances of the particular site.   

 

 

Capitalisation Rates derived from Former Leased Quarries

 

Capitalisation rates are also derived from quarry sales transactions which involve a lease, whereby the tenant has acquired the landlords interest to create a freehold interest. We have market evidence of several transactions for these type of sales, but many of the transactions tend to show slightly lower capitalisation rates as compared to business sales, and this can be due to under assessed royalties, restrictive lease conditions, the negotiating strengths of the tenant, in that if the tenant does not obtain favourable terms, then they can continue with the lease instead, and a variety of other reasons.

 

For clarity we have also plotted our lease evidence from market sales to all of the above charts, and interestingly the additional data has derived virtual horizontal trend lines over the longer and shorter term. However there are some other notable differences between the capitalisation rates adopted for business sales as compared to lease evidence derived from a tenant acquiring the freehold, in that the business sales are based on the profits of the quarry operation, whilst the lease sales are based on the rental value of the royalty. Therefore it very much depends upon the purpose of the valuation as to which method of valuation the valuer would be using, which is typically either the Going Concern value, which is based on the actual quarry profits, or the asset value, which is based on the rental value of the quarry, with both methods then capitalising the profits or rentals over the life of the quarry.

 

Premiums and Discounts

 

A Premium is the term used for market sales transactions, where it is perceived that the purchaser has paid over and above the market value for a business. There are a number of reasons why a quarry company may be prepared to pay a premium. A n existing competing quarry company may be prepared to pay a premium to gain market share, and they could also transfer their mineral production to the site, and in effect significantly increase the value of the site by increasing the output. Alternatively a new company to the market may be prepared to pay a premium to be able to enter the market. There could also be synergies by incorporating the management of the business into their own business, but also there are often supply benefits for pre mixed concrete plants, which can secure cements supplies controlled by the purchaser. But also where an existing quarry business owner does not wish to sell, then often the purchaser has to offer a premium over and above the market value to entice the owner to sell, as everyone has their price.

 

A Discount is the opposite of a premium, in that the quarry business owner is desirous to sell, whilst the quarry buyer is not necessarily in the market to buy, but if the sale is made attractive, by offering a discount to the perceived market value, then they would acquire the business.

 

In certain circumstances then the purchasers of quarry businesses can be considered to be Special Purchasers as due to them operating other similar businesses in a given area, then they can afford to pay premiums where an acquisition can benefit their existing business. Where you have a Special Purchaser sale, then this is not considered to form the market value based on the definition from the International Valuation Standards Committee and endorsed by the Australian Property Institute, and so the sale would then contain either a Premium or Discount, which in effect would be the difference between the actual purchase price and the market value.

 

Rogue Sales and Over Valuation

 

There is a notable difference between Premiums and Discounts and Rogue Sales, in that Premiums and Discounts are often quantifiable whereby the benefits can be easily identified and equated into a benefit to other parts of the purchasers business. However for rogue sales there are often no such benefits, in that the purchaser does not own any other operations where values can be transferred or synergies gained and is merely an overpayment for a particular quarry business. There are a number of rogue sales currently in the market, whereby the purchasers of a quarry, have paid well in excess of the perceived market value. These sales tend to involve new entrants to the market, whose lack of experience and understanding of the mechanisms of the industry, then makes it difficult for them to compete in the market and ultimately often ends up with the business failing a few years later. Many of these rogue sales are easily identified as existing quarry owners tend to quote them, as being comparable to their quarry, at the time of a valuation. But also capitalisation rates for rogue sales have been as low as 6.00%, which nowhere near reflects the risks of the business. Many of these sales do take several years to unfold, and typically go back on the market for over inflated asking prices, until the financiers pull the plug on the business.

 

There are many instances of inexperienced quarry buyers convincing inexperienced valuers, who often act for major banks, that a purchase is viable, especially when they quote other rouge sales as being the norm within a particular area or region. This often then adds to the problem, especially for the banks, who are often completely unaware of the additional risks they are exposed to. However this scenario has changed somewhat following the GFC, as banks have reduced their loan to values for quarry acquisitions or lending purposes, and many new entrants to the quarry industry, are no longer willing to risk a higher proportion of their own money and so there have been fewer rogue sales since the GFC. However there are still a number of past rogue sales where the banks have taken a larger slice of the risk and which may come to market at some point.

 

So the main drivers of over valuation tend to firstly involve the incorrect application of capitalisation rates which artificially inflate values, but do not reflect the actual risks of the business. If a purchaser has overpaid for a quarry business, then quite often the return on capital factors through to the selling prices of the products, and often makes them uncompetitive compared to rival operators, and in turn, reduces the outputs and profits until such stage as the quarry business fails. The other main driver of over valuation involves the value in the ground methodology of a quarry resource, whereby quite often a quarry owner has been advised by a mineral investigation operator, who benefits by carrying out work for the owner, in that the more investigation work they do, the more valuable the resource. However this is often not the case, as it is the market demand that drives the value of a quarry business, and not the market supply. Although it is not just the quarry owners who are exposed to these risks but often the banks who are financing these operations, and quite often they are unaware of the risks they have exposed themselves to until it is often too late.   

 

The opinions expressed in the above paper are the personal views of the author gained from experience and research within the extractive industries. No responsibilities can be held for any person or company who relies on information within this paper or who attempts to take any extracts from this paper. This paper is not to be used or quoted in part or as a whole for commercial use without the express written consent of the author.

 

Stephens Valuation & Consultancy Pty Ltd

 
By Roderick Stephens BSc (Hons) MC MRICS AAPI (CPV)

Certified Practising Valuer

Chartered Mineral Surveyor

Registered Valuer NSW, QLD & WA

PO Box 404

Emu Plains

NSW 2750

Tel No:  02 *4704 *8483         

E mail: rodstephens@optusnet.com.au

Mobile 0423 *383 *343

Website: www.quarryvaluations.com which is a Registered Trade Mark
quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone   nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt  nab anz cba st george suncorp westpac credit finance loan to value loans business banking brokers rba interest rates cash bonds national australia bank bendigo adelaide queensland of bank mortgage debt
 leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases quarry royalties royalty quarries value valuation valuer nsw qld vic queensland victoria au australia nz com sales rock gravel sand stone sandstone limestone leases